Selecting an Actuator Type during Control System Design

The choice of actuator type affects system performance, reliability, efficiency, and overall control system design.

A control system is an essential part of many products and processes, helping to ensure that they operate safely and effectively. Understanding actuator types is essential for control system design because the actuator is responsible for converting control signals into physical actions or outputs. By understanding actuator types, designers can select actuators that are compatible with control signals, exhibit desired response dynamics, provide required force or displacement capabilities, ensure energy efficiency, meet physical constraints, enhance system reliability, and align with cost considerations. 

What is a Control System? 

A control system is a set of components and processes that work together to manage, regulate, and control the behavior of a system. All control systems, such as a mechanical governor on an engine or a digital thermostat on an electrical heater, are designed to ensure that the system behaves in a desired manner by regulating its inputs, processes, and outputs. Control systems are widely used in engineering, physics, chemistry, and other fields where it is necessary to maintain stability and optimize performance of a system.

Control systems are found in equipment and devices we encounter everyday, including: 

• Robotic Systems
• Motion Control Systems
• Thermostatic Controls
• Unmanned Vehicle Systems
• Smart Guidance Systems, and more.

Read more about Control Systems 

What actuator types are available for use in a Control System?

There are numerous actuator types available, each suitable for different control system requirements and applications. The choice of actuator depends on factors such as the desired motion, precision, force or torque requirements, speed, and environmental considerations. Here are 10 examples to consider: 

• Electric Motors: Electric motors convert electrical energy into mechanical motion and are widely used in various applications, including robotics, industrial automation, and HVAC systems.
  
  
• Hydraulic Cylinders: Hydraulic cylinders use pressurized fluid to create linear motion and are commonly employed in heavy-duty industrial machinery, construction equipment, and vehicle control systems.
  
  
• Pneumatic Actuators: Pneumatic actuators use compressed air to generate linear or rotary motion and are found in applications such as control valves, robotic systems, and pneumatic tools.
  
  
• Servo Motors: Servo motors are precise and highly controllable electric motors used in applications that require accurate positioning, such as CNC machines, robotic arms, and aerospace systems.
  
  
• Solenoid Valves: Solenoid valves control the flow of fluids or gases by utilizing an electromagnetic coil to actuate a valve mechanism. They are widely used in industrial automation, irrigation systems, and HVAC systems.
  
  
• Piezoelectric Actuators: Piezoelectric actuators employ the piezoelectric effect to convert electrical energy into mechanical motion. They are commonly used in precision positioning systems, nano-positioning devices, and microelectromechanical systems (MEMS).
  
  
• Stepper Motors: Stepper motors divide a full rotation into discrete steps and are used in applications that require precise angular positioning, such as 3D printers, CNC machines, and robotics.
  
  
• Electromagnetic Actuators: Electromagnetic actuators use the magnetic field generated by an electric current to produce linear or rotary motion. They are utilized in various applications, including relays, switches, and magnetic levitation systems.
  
  
• Shape Memory Alloys (SMAs): SMAs are alloys that exhibit shape memory properties, allowing them to recover their original shape when heated. They are used as actuators in applications such as biomedical devices, aerospace systems, and robotics.
  
  
• Rotary Actuators: Rotary actuators provide rotational motion and are available in various forms, including gear-driven actuators, rotary pneumatic actuators, and hydraulic rotary actuators. They are used in applications such as industrial machinery, robotics, and control valves. 
  
  

Understanding actuator type is crucial to control system design 

• Compatibility with Control Signals: Different actuators require different types of control signals for operation. For example, electric motors typically require voltage or current signals, while hydraulic actuators require pressure or flow signals. Understanding the actuator type ensures that the control system generates compatible control signals that can be effectively translated into desired physical actions.
• Response Dynamics: Actuators exhibit specific response dynamics, including rise time, settling time, and overshoot. These characteristics impact the overall control system's performance, especially in applications where precise and rapid control is required. By understanding the response dynamics of different actuator types, designers can choose actuators that match the desired control system performance and meet the specific application requirements.
• Force, Torque, or Displacement Capability: Actuators have different force, torque, or displacement capabilities, depending on their design and construction. Understanding these capabilities is crucial for selecting an actuator that can generate the required output or physical action to achieve the control objectives. For example, in robotics applications, the choice of actuator type affects the robot's payload capacity, reach, and dexterity.
• Energy Efficiency: Actuators consume energy to generate physical output. Different actuator types have varying energy efficiency characteristics. By understanding the energy efficiency of different actuators, designers can select actuators that minimize energy consumption and optimize overall system efficiency, especially in applications where energy efficiency is a critical factor.
• Physical Constraints and Environmental Considerations: Actuators may have physical constraints or limitations, such as size, weight, operating temperature range, or resistance to vibration or corrosion. Understanding these constraints is important to ensure the actuator can operate reliably in the specific application environment. It allows designers to select actuators that can withstand the physical conditions and environmental factors present in the application.
• Maintenance and Reliability: Actuator type affects maintenance requirements and overall system reliability. Different actuators have different maintenance needs, such as lubrication, calibration, or periodic inspections. Understanding the maintenance requirements and reliability characteristics of different actuator types helps in designing a control system that minimizes downtime and ensures long-term reliability.
• Cost Considerations: Actuator type can significantly impact the cost of the control system. Actuators vary in terms of initial cost, operational cost, and maintenance cost. Understanding the cost implications of different actuator types allows designers to make informed decisions regarding the control system's affordability while considering the required performance and specifications. 

Ready to Begin your next Control System Design? 

Whether you’re looking to enhance your current team or outsource a solution to meet rising demands on your time, working with Boston Engineering control systems experts is the right choice. Don't leave complex designs that rely on layers of integration to slow down your team, extend deadlines, or even worse: cause a project failure. Know you're going to get the results you want by working with an industry leader in development and deployment of high performance control  systems. 

Let's start the Control Systems conversation

No matter the challenge, our team possesses the expertise in the engineering disciplines and technologies you need to bring your vision to life. Impossible Challenge? Try Us.

Imagine your Impact: Stay up-to date- with the latest insights and trends we're watching. Add your email address below and sign up for a Monthly Summary of our most impactful posts!