The challenge of extending medical device lifespans can be successfully navigated with careful planning, strategic investments, and a long-term perspective.
While extending the life of existing medical devices can be a cost-effective strategy, it comes with its own set of challenges. Let's explore these challenges, strategies to mitigate them, and the business case for addressing each issue.
The focus and discipline of DFX is a powerful tool if used as part of a broader strategic approach to developing product/process differentiation, and a sustainable advantage against competition. Involve Design for X in Strategy. Once your team has determined the focus of your strategy, place the focus of design on developing competitive advantage.
At Boston Engineering, DFX is a core part of creating values during our product development process. We focus on several key DFX areas that align with our expertise:
- Design for Manufacturability (DFM)
- Design for Assembly (DFA)
- Design for Cost (DFC)
- Design for Testability (DFT)
- Design for Reliability (DFR)
- Design for Serviceability/Maintainability (DFS)
- Design for Usability (DFU)
- Design for Modularity (DFMo)
Learn more about Design for X (DFX) at Boston engineering: Boston Engineering Design for X
(continued from above)
1. Limited Innovation
Example: A cardiac monitoring company updating its existing Holter monitor with minor software improvements.
Mitigation Strategy: Implement a robust market research program to identify unmet user needs. Establish an innovation lab focused on integrating cutting-edge technologies into existing products.
Business Case: While not as groundbreaking as a new product, strategic innovations can significantly extend product lifespan and maintain market relevance.
Financial Impact: Investing 5-7% of annual revenues in an innovation program could lead to feature improvements that increase sales by 15-20% and extend product lifespan by 3-5 years.
2. Market Saturation
Example: An infusion pump manufacturer releasing a slightly updated version of its bestselling model.
Mitigation Strategy: Focus on expanding into new market segments or geographic regions. Develop value-added services or accessories to differentiate the product.
Business Case: Entering new markets or adding complementary services can open new revenue streams and reinvigorate sales of mature products.
Financial Impact: Expansion into new markets might require a 10-15% increase in marketing budget but could potentially increase overall sales by 25-30% over 2-3 years.
3. Missed Opportunities
Example: A surgical instrument company focusing on incremental improvements to existing scalpels while competitors develop laser-based alternatives.
Mitigation Strategy: Establish a dedicated team for monitoring emerging technologies and market trends. Develop partnerships or licensing agreements with innovative startups.
Business Case: Staying ahead of market trends can prevent being blindsided by disruptive technologies and maintain long-term competitiveness.
Financial Impact: Allocating 2-3% of annual revenue to trend monitoring and partnership development could prevent potential losses of 30-40% market share to disruptive competitors.
4. Diminishing Returns
Example: A blood glucose meter company releasing its fifth incremental update with marginal improvements in accuracy.
Mitigation Strategy: Focus on cost reduction and efficiency improvements. Explore adjacent markets where existing technology can be applied in novel ways.
Business Case: Even with diminishing technical returns, operational improvements can maintain profitability, while market expansion can drive growth.
Financial Impact: A focus on operational efficiency might yield 5-10% cost savings, offsetting the impact of slowing sales growth.
AL & ML in Health Care - The Medical Workplace Multiplier
In this new Whitepaper, learn how AI and ML can enhance the medical workforce’s abilities and improve patient outcomes.
While some view AI as a potential job replacement threat, the reality is that these advanced capabilities are better positioned as “workforce multipliers” that will amplify the abilities of doctors, nurses, technicians and other medical professionals.
Download your Free Copy Today!
Artificial intelligence and machine learning are emerging technologies that have immense potential to reshape healthcare delivery and medical practice.
5. Competitive Pressure
Example: An X-ray machine manufacturer continuing to update its analog systems while the market shifts to digital.
Mitigation Strategy: Develop a clear technology roadmap with defined triggers for more significant upgrades or pivots. Build modularity into product design to allow for easier future upgrades.
Business Case: A well-planned roadmap can balance the benefits of product longevity with the need to stay competitive, ensuring timely larger-scale updates.
Financial Impact: Investment in a modular design approach might increase development costs by 15-20% but could reduce the cost of future major upgrades by 40-50%.
By proactively addressing these challenges, medical device companies can maximize the benefits of extending product lifespans while minimizing the risks. The key is to balance the cost savings of product extensions with strategic investments in innovation and market responsiveness.
Example Business Cases
For instance, the cardiac monitoring company's investment in an innovation lab might seem unnecessary for a mature product like a Holter monitor. However, integrating features like real-time data transmission or AI-assisted analysis could rejuvenate the product line, potentially extending its market viability by several years and staving off competition from more innovative startups.
The infusion pump manufacturer's strategy of expanding into new markets might require significant upfront investment in regulatory approvals and marketing. However, in a saturated home market, this could be the key to maintaining growth and leveraging existing manufacturing capabilities.
For the surgical instrument company, the investment in monitoring emerging technologies might seem like a distraction from their core business. However, in a field where a disruptive technology could rapidly make traditional tools obsolete, this vigilance is crucial for long-term survival.
The blood glucose meter company's focus on operational efficiency might not be as exciting as developing new features. However, in a mature market with intense price competition, this could be the key to maintaining profitability and funding future innovations.
Lastly, the X-ray machine manufacturer's investment in a modular design approach might seem excessive for incremental updates. However, in a rapidly evolving field like medical imaging, this modularity could be the difference between a smooth transition to new technologies and a costly, disruptive overhaul.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while extending the life of existing medical devices can be a sound business strategy, it requires careful management to avoid stagnation and loss of market position. By combining thoughtful product updates with strategic investments in innovation, market expansion, and operational efficiency, companies can maximize the value of their existing product lines while positioning themselves for future growth. The key is to view product life extension not as a way to avoid change, but as a platform for sustainable, measured evolution in a rapidly changing market.
New eBook Available Now!
"Leveling Up Existing Products through DFX"
-Download Insights from a DFX Subject Matter Expert-
Developing successful new products from scratch is challenging enough, but what about improving on existing designs?
In this eBook, we’ll dive into the real-world experiences of DFX subject matter expert John DePiano, exploring the common areas where existing product owners excel, as well as the key opportunities where targeted DFX support can drive major improvements.
Understanding the Importance of a DFX approach in medical device design & development
Applying Design for X (DFX) methodologies upfront in medical device development optimizes the entire lifecycle by improving manufacturability, testability, reliability, usability, and other critical characteristics. This avoids costly redesigns later on, facilitates high-quality products that satisfy customers, reduces manufacturing and service costs, and supports flexibility through modularity and platforms. The holistic perspective of DFX drives efficient, cost-effective delivery of successful products that provide competitive advantage. Investing in DFX early pays dividends across the entire product lifespan.
Do you offer training on DFX for your medical engineering teams?
Education is critical to effectively implement DFX principles. We provide training tailored to your engineers’ roles and product lines. This includes overall DFX methodology, deep dives into specific disciplines like design for reliability or manufacturability, and practical application workshops. Our hands-on approach combines real-world examples and case studies with tutorials on leading DFX software tools. The goal is building organizational DFX expertise and establishing repeatable processes that endure beyond individual projects. Investing in DFX knowledge pays dividends across your entire product portfolio.
Ready to Begin your next medical device DFX Project?
Whether you’ve created a new technology, or have an innovative way to use an existing solution, Boston Engineering will turn your ideas into reality. Our experts and Industry Partners will enhance your current team or manage the entire Product Development Process from Market Analysis to Production. Don't leave complex projects or high visibility product launches to chance. Know you're going to get the results you want by working with industry leaders in design, development, and deployment of innovative products driven by Novel Engineering. Contact Boston Engineering Today to get started.
No matter the challenge, our team possesses the expertise in the engineering disciplines and technologies you need to bring your vision to life. Impossible Challenge? Try Us.
-1.png?width=2000&height=279&name=MED%20Coffee%20Talk%20Mastering%20Use%20Cases%20%26%20Cybersecurity%20(2)-1.png)
Impossible Challenge? Try Us.
Selecting a partner to help you complete your design project is a valuable option to reduce project duration and save money.
The Boston Engineering product development system encompasses DFX to ensure a smooth product launch and success in the marketplace. Boston Engineering has DFX knowledge and experience to address aspects and values of a product such as manufacturability, test, reliability, safety, serviceability, cost, and compliance with industry standards and government regulations.
Imagine your Impact: Stay up-to date- with the latest insights and trends we're watching. Add your email address below and sign up for a Monthly Summary of our most impactful posts!
